Specific Crops - Cole
Crops
Introduction
This group of crops belongs to the family Cruciferae, and is thus also
referred to as cruciferous crops or crucifers. The commercially important
crops all belong to the genus Brassica, hence the reference to brassica
crops or simply brassicas.
The botanical names of these crops, arranged in order of commercial
importance in South Africa, are:
- Cabbage - Brassica oleracea L. var. capitata.
- Cauliflower - B. oleracea L. var. botrytis
- Sprouting broccoli (or calabrese) - B. oleracea L. var. italica.
- Brussels sprouts - B. oleracea L. var. gemmifera.
Some other vegetables in the same family include chinese cabbage,
choumoellier , horseradish, kohlrabi, kale, various mustards, radish, turnip,
swede (or rutabago), as well as a number of lesser-known vegetables.
There are also several important, usually winter, cruciferous weeds such as
pepperweed, shepherd's purse, wild mustard and wild radish.
A point to remember with all the above plants is that they are closely
related, and have similar climatic requirements, and are usually attacked by a
similar range of pests and diseases. However, cole crop requirements, though
similar, are not identical and there may also be larger differences in
requirements between different horticultural cultivars of, for example,
cabbage, than there generally are between cabbage and cauliflower.
Over a period of time, plant breeders have developed many different
varieties within any of the above groups of vegetables, so that cultivars may
differ greatly in shape, colour, length of growing season, compactness of
head, tolerance to heat or cold, tolerance to specific diseases, and so on.
Environmental Requirements
Climate
The cruciferous crops may all be classified as cool-season plants,
and make best growth under cool, moist conditions.
Cabbage
Best yields and quality are normally obtained from crops maturing
during the cooler months from autumn to spring. The optimum mean temperature
is about 17ºC, with an average maximum of 24ºC,
and an average minimum of 4 or 5ºC. Cabbages are
fairly resistant to frost and hardy varieties will often survive minimum
temperature as low as minus 3ºC without obvious
damage. However plants, especially young plants and mature heads, are much
more sensitive to cold when temperature differences between day and night are
large, or where sudden cold snaps occur.
Notwithstanding the above, cabbages are fairly well-adapted to growing
under warmer conditions; some varieties much more so than others. They can
thus be grown virtually throughout the year in all but the hotter areas of the
country. Yield and quality are, however, poorer under hot and dry conditions,
when a strong bitter taste may develop. Summer cabbage crops are generally not
as successful as those harvested under cooler conditions. Various pests and
diseases are also more prevalent and difficult to control during summer, and
these further reduce yield and quality of such crops.
Cauliflower
Cauliflower has a very similar temperature and moisture requirement
to that of cabbages for optimum growth and development, but is much less
adapted to extremes of heat or cold. Growth is also poorer at mean minimums of
less than 7ºC. Mature curds, if not protected by
leaves, can be easily damaged by only a few degrees of frost. Heavy frosts can
cause serious damage to the crop, particularly with sudden cold snaps.
Cauliflower will also seldom give an acceptable yield or quality if it matures
during hotter weather. Production is thus generally limited to autumn, winter
(except in very cold areas) and spring. Nevertheless, growers in areas with
cool conditions during the summer months have the opportunity of realising
premium prices for their crops when there is the demand for cauliflower on
tables during special occasions such as holidays.
Broccoli
Once again cool, moist conditions are best. This crop also cannot
withstand quite the same degree of extreme temperatures that cabbages can, but
it will be much better than cauliflower with variations from the optimum
conditions. Under high temperature conditions, the heads may turn an
unattractive yellowish-beige colour, particularly after harvesting, but it can
occur before harvest. Broccoli also has a tendency to abscission or partial
abscission of buds leading to a condition known as "brown bud". It
is generally accepted that it is more common with certain cultivars when they
are growing under stress. Observation suggest that the problem is more common
when cold snaps are followed by periods of warm weather. The problem is worse
on the more mature heads. It can be alleviated by harvesting more sharply
(taking less-mature heads than normal) and at shorter intervals, when such
conditions prevail.
Brussels sprout
This crop can withstand colder conditions than cabbage, but is
probably more sensitive to high temperatures than even cauliflower. Under high
temperature conditions most varieties produce loose, open ("blown")
sprouts, which have no value. Brussels sprouts should thus be grown for
harvest during the coolest period of the year (winter) in most areas. Many of
the European varieties produce mainly "blown" sprouts even under
winter conditions in many of South Africa’s subtropical areas. Cold weather
produces firm, tight sprouts with a sweeter flavour.
Brassicas are all biennial crops, which normally require some colder
temperatures to induce seeding. If young plants are subjected to prolonged
exposure to temperatures less than about 7ºC,
they frequently bolt to seed in spring before making an economic crop. Plants
sown just before, or during, winter are more inclined to bolt. This bolting
tendency is aggravated by drought, poor nutrition and other stress factors.
Certain cultivars are much less prone to bolting than others.
Soils
Brassicas are fairly heavy feeders. They grow well on soils with a
high organic matter content. They can be grown successfully on a great variety
of soils, varying from sands to fairly heavy clay, provided the soil is
fertile and suitably drained, yet having no lack of moisture.
They do best on deep, heavy loams. The crop should never lack nutrients or
water, so the less fertile and hotter, drier, light soils are less suitable -
such soils can obviously be used successfully if well fertilized, especially
with the addition of organic manures to which these crops respond particularly
well, and if more careful attention is paid to good irrigation practices.
Compacted soils are also less suitable. Should crusting occur after rain or
irrigation, loosening such soil by tillage is important in the early growth
stages at least
Cultivars
There are a number of cultivars available in the seed trade, with
new ones continually being developed. It is a good practice to keep in touch
with seedsmen to get their latest recommendations on cultivars possibly more
suited to the local conditions and the planned planting times.
Some of the most popular cultivars in KwaZulu-Natal are as follows:
Cabbage
The older open-pollinated cultivars still being grown include Cape
Spitz, Drumhead and Glory of Enkhuizen. Gloria is also popular in some areas,
even though it is susceptible to Black Rot, as are the three cultivars
mentioned above. The most popular commercial cultivars are all hybrids and all
show some tolerance to Black Rot. They include:
Conquistador, Green Coronet, Green Crown, Grand Slam and Star 3306 for
production during the cool season. Cultivars with a greater measure of
heat-tolerance include the well-known Hercules and Green Star, as well as
Centauro, Beverly Hills, Star 3301 and Star 3304.
Cauliflower
Popular cultivars include Incline, Glacier, Arizona, Fremont, Siria,
Star 4403, Star 4405 and Tenere.
Broccoli
Green Valiant is possibly the most popular, but fair-sized
plantings of Liberty, Pirate, Star 2201 and Viking are also made.
Brussels Sprouts
The crop is seldom grown commercially in KZN. The cultivars Amarosa,
Jade Cross and Prince Marrel are grown on a small scale. Long Island is grown
in home gardens.
Table 14: Sowing times
|
|
Cold areas
Heavy frost |
Warm areas
Light Frost |
Hot areas
Frost free |
|
Cabbage |
September - February |
All year |
Feb - June/July |
|
Cauliflower |
December - Feb/March
August - September |
January - April
July - September |
Feb - March/April |
|
Broccoli |
September - January |
January - September |
Feb - June/July |
| Brussels sprouts |
Nov/Dec - February |
January - March |
Feb - April |
Cultural Aspects
Direct seeding
In many instances, particularly in the more advanced countries
where labour is expensive and in short supply, direct seeding in the
commercial field is the rule. However, this practice is seldom followed in
South Africa, for several very good reasons:
- the harsh climate,
- lack of solid-set sprinklers,
- the inability to control weeds adequately on the larger land.
This method is finding more favour in South Africa as better equipment
becomes available and labour becomes more of a problem. However, it can be
recommended only where individual sowings at any one time are relatively
small, where irrigation equipment allows for frequent watering, where
excellent pre-plant weed control has been achieved or the weed pressure is low
and, for preference, when sowing during the cooler, yet moist, months of the
year. Seed usage is several times higher with direct seeding than where
transplants are used. Up to 2 kg of seed per hectare may be required. Thinning
out to the desired stand is necessary. Seedlings should emerge within about 5
days at soil temperatures of 20ºC to 30ºC,
but may take two or three weeks to appear at temperatures of 10ºC.
Usually there is no germination at temperatures below 5ºC
or above 35ºC.
Seedbeds
A more normal method is to sow in well-prepared seedbeds and to
transplant the seedlings when they are sufficiently developed. The soil and
fertility requirements for seedbeds are the same as those for the land. Soils
which cap should be avoided. Seedbeds should not be made on any site where
crucifers have been grown within the past three years. Sites for seedbeds
should not be exposed to very strong winds, but there should be good air
movement to reduce disease incidence. Avoid sites too close to rivers or
streams, or where dew is heavy, for the same reason. However, easy access to
irrigation water is essential.
The site should be fully exposed to the sun, and not too close to
competitive tree roots.
Seedbeds should have a firm, level surface; low spots become too wet at
times and high spots are often too dry. Beds should be no more than 1 m in
width and of any convenient length, with narrow access paths between them.
They are often raised a few centimetres above the normal soil surface to
reduce the chance of water-logging should heavy rains occur.
Use a minimum of 300 square metres of bed for every 500 g of seed sown.
Denser plantings will tend to produce unsuitably long, thin, lanky seedlings,
which do not perform well. Seed is sown thinly to a depth of not more than 15
mm, in rows drawn 150 to 200 mm apart. Although seed size (usually 200 to 300
seeds/g) and germination do vary, a rule of thumb is to plant about 60 to 70 g
of seed for every 10 000 transplants required, where seedbed conditions are
good. Many growers plant about 10% more seed than they require, to ensure that
sufficient seedlings are available to fill the entire land.
Frequent light irrigations are necessary to prevent drying out of the top
soil in which the seed is planted. Gradually increase the interval between
irrigations to about 7 days when the plants are well-established.
Drenching the soil just after emergence with Previcur N or Proplant can
reduce the incidence of "damping-off", caused by various soil fungi.
Spray the young seedlings (weekly) with a suitable fungicide as a routine
spray or at the first signs of Downy Mildew. The danger of outbreak of
seedling diseases rises considerably under conditions of overcrowding,
inadequate ventilation and poor drainage from the seedbed.
Spray with sodium or ammonium molybdate when the seedlings are 3 to 4 weeks
old where molybdenum deficiencies are known to occur, and follow this a week
later with a solubor spray where the soil is deficient in boron.
Keep the seedlings moist and growing strongly for 3 to 6 weeks or until
they are 7 to 10 cm tall. Then reduce watering over the last 7 to 10 days (but
do not allow the plants to wilt severely) in order to harden them to withstand
the shock of transplanting. Give the seedbeds a good soaking the day before
transplanting in order to restore a good water regime in the seedlings, and to
facilitate lifting of the plants with minimal root damage.
Short, sturdy, slightly hardened seedlings about 10 to 15 cm tall, and with
4 to 5 true leaves, transplant and perform better than soft lanky, etiolated
plants. The latter develop as a result of sowing too densely (seedbed area is
too small), over-use of nitrogen fertilizers and over-watering. Under warm
conditions, Brassica seedlings may reach the required size within 4 to 5
weeks, but under cooler conditions may take 7 or 8 weeks, even with good
seedbed practice. Young plants of the required size yield better than older
ones. Only those plants which have reached the desired size are used for
transplanting. Those developing more slowly may be transplanted slightly later
when they are more developed, but are ultimately less likely to perform as
well.
Seed Trays
As an alternative to open seedbeds, most commercial and many
small-scale growers in KZN produce their plants in styrofoam or similar trays
(the so-called speedling system), or purchase plants from specialised
nurseries who use this system. Whilst this system has certain advantages,
particularly for those growers who cannot produce seedlings well in open
seedbeds, there are also some disadvantages. Even comparatively poor or
off-type plants (so-called sibs) are often usable from such seedlings, but
would probably not be used from seedbeds, and the high cost of transplants may
cause some growers to revert to open seedbeds, particularly for
open-pollinated varieties or those with less expensive hybrid cultivars.
However, there is a saving in seed cost, and speedlings transplant more
successfully, and with most growers perform better, with a more uniform,
concentrated maturity, than do seedlings raised in seedbeds.
Transplanting
It is obvious from the afore-going that selected, well-hardened,
young, stocky plants should be used. Weak plants or those showing any
abnormality, such as double-stem, no growing point, or diseased roots or
stems, should in no circumstances be used. Transplant as soon as the plants
reach the desired size. Have sufficient seedlings to be in a position to
ruthlessly discard poor plants. Try to use "first full" plants only,
as far as possible.
Lift plants carefully with as little root damage as possible, moisten them
if necessary and cover them with moist sacking until transplanted. Lift only
sufficient plants at a time to keep the planters busy.
Plant into moist soil for preference, firm the soil around the roots and
irrigate again as soon as possible after setting the seedlings. Ensure that
the roots of the seedling point straight down and are not bent during the
planting process. Ensure that the correct spacing and plant population is
achieved. Planting out on raised beds or ridges is advisable in wet areas, to
reduce the risk of water-logging and stem or root rots.
Spacing
Spacing and plant population affect head size, head shape and
yield. Should the specific market demand be for large heads, then wider
spacings and lower population, will be adopted for any specific variety than
where the market prefers smaller heads. With broccoli there is a strong
tendency for the denser plantings to produce a much larger portion of the
total yield from the main heads rather than from the less popular side
sprouts. With the exception of brussel sprouts, where individual sprout size
is hardly affected by spacing, the denser the planting (within limits), the
larger the total yield, but the smaller the heads. Generally speaking it is
found that most growers tend to under-plant, i.e. have lower than optimum
population.
The size of the tractor and implements available will very often determine
the row spacings used.
Bearing the above comments in mind, the following spacings are suggested:
- Large-headed types: 500 mm to 600 mm x 400 mm to 500 mm (40 000 to 45
000 plants per hectare).
- Medium-headed types: 500 mm to 600 mm x 300 mm to 400 mm (55 000 to 65
000 plants per hectare).
- Baby cabbages: 300 mm to 350 mm square (80 000 to 100 000 plants per
hectare)
- Large-framed varieties: 750 mm to 900 mm x 500 mm to 600 mm (about 22
000 plants per hectare).
- Small-framed varieties: 600 mm to 750 mm x 400 mm to 450 mm (about 35
000 plants per hectare).
- Large-framed varieties: 600 mm to 750 mm x 400 mm to 500 mm (about 33
000 plants per hectare).
- Small-framed varieties: 600 mm to 750 mm x 300 mm to 350 mm (about 45
000 plants per hectare).
- All varieties: 900 mm to 100 mm x 450 mm to 500 mm (about 22 000
plants per hectare).
Rotational cropping
A three- or even four-year rotation is advisable for cole crops,
mainly to reduce the risk of disease build-up. Cruciferous weeds must be
rigorously controlled during the period when cole crops are not grown, or
otherwise much of the benefit of crop rotation can be lost.
"Topping" of Brussels sprouts
Artificial stopping of the plants is done on most factory crops, by
removal of, or damage to, the growing point of the stem. Disbudding is usually
carried out by hand in South Africa, but the use of rubber mallets to crush
the growing point is sometimes used. If not stopped, the plant will usually
develop a smallish head - nearly tennis ball size - at the growing point, when
cold weather sets in. Should this occur the yield of sprouts is lowered.
Stopping is usually done when the plant has developed to the 25th to 30th set
of leaves, counted in the natural spiral in which they occur on the stem, or
else at about the time of first pick.
Stripping of lower sprouts on Brussels sprouts
This is practised only where the sprouts at the base of the plant,
often worthless where the lower leaves have dropped, are badly infested with
insects (especially aphids), or where they are badly diseased with, for
example, black rot. Stripping these lower sprouts tends to reduce the insect
or disease pressure on sprouts higher up the stem, and also allows spray
chemicals more easily to penetrate to the remaining sprouts.
Tieing of cauliflower leaves
Where cauliflower curds are exposed to the sun, they tend to
discolour and lose the desired whiteness. Some cultivars have good wrapper
leaves around the curd and are naturally well-protected. Others are more open
and the tieing up of long leaves round the curds to protect them is often
resorted to. On hot days cauliflower plants often wilt quite severely, even
when soil moisture is adequate. This will often expose the heads, even on
cultivars with better natural protection, and tieing up of leaves can reduce
the problem of discolouration.
Fertilizers
Cole crops have a high nutritional requirement. In many areas of
KZN the main factors that limit yield are soil acidity, low soil phosphorus
status, low soil nitrogen and potassium levels, and low or unavailable
molybdenum. Suitable fertilizer programmes, based on reliable soil analyses,
should be developed for each field. These crops also respond very well to
organic manuring. Commercial production of brassica crops is conducted on
lands which are intensively used in many areas. Because of this there is
possibly a build-up of one of more of the major elements, and recommendations
for fertilized rates based on a reliable soil analysis can result in
significant cost reductions.
Soil acidity
Brassicas are sensitive to soil acidity. Soils of low pH often
contain very high levels of available aluminium and manganese, which adversely
affect growth and yield. Under such conditions aluminium can be deposited in
the leaf veins, the lower epidermis of which often tends to crack open. High
levels of available aluminium will tend to immobilize soil phosphorus,
rendering it unavailable to the plant, giving rise to phosphorus deficiencies.
Manganese toxicity may also be a problem on very acid soils, especially on the
heavier soils favoured by cole crops. Molybdenum deficiencies may be induced
on very acid soils, even where soil molybdenum levels are adequate. Cole crops
have a particularly high molybdenum requirement.
pH (KCI) should be raised to over 5,5 and acid saturation of the soil
reduced to below 2%, preferably 0%, before planting, by liming the soil.
Liming will also increase the decomposition of plant residues in the soil,
releasing more plant nutrients and making soil nutrients, such as molybdenum
and phosphorus, more available.
Macro-nutrients
Nitrogen (N)
The nitrogen requirement of cole crops is relatively high. It is
generally accepted that high-yielding crops, such as cabbages, as well as
those with long growing seasons, such as Brussels sprouts or late-maturing
large-framed cauliflower (like Snowcap), require 200 kg to 250 kg nitrogen per
hectare. Broccoli and early-maturing cauliflower need 150 kg to 200 kg
nitrogen for good yields. Half to two-thirds of the nitrogen is broadcast and
ploughed in shortly before planting, together with the phosphorus and
potassium requirements. The rest of the nitrogen is applied as side-dressings,
early in growth; usually 2 to 3 weeks after transplanting and again about 3
weeks later, or all at about 6 weeks. On sandy soils subject to leaching more
of the nitrogen is applied as side-dressings than is the case on heavier
soils.
Deficiency symptoms are that leaves are smaller than normal, with an
overall pale green or yellowish colour. The lower, more mature leaves are
affected first, but all leaves may be deficient in severe cases. Stems tend to
be thin and hard. Plants grow slowly.
Phosphorus (P)
Phosphorus promotes root development and thus ensures more vigorous
growth, especially of young plants. Where the phosphorus status of the soil
has been built up over several years, 40 kg of applied P per hectare should be
adequate for most crops. On the more acid soils, or on soils deficient in
phosphorus, best results are obtained by banding the fertilizer.
Plants deficient in this element also tend to grow slowly. Stems are thin
and shortened. Leaves develop a purple coloration, first on the underside, and
later throughout. Older leaves are affected first.
Potassium (K)
The potassium usage of cole crops is also high. Plant analyses
indicate that they take up approximately as much potassium as nitrogen.
Although total yields are seldom affected, except where severe deficiencies
occur, quality is reduced. Heads tend to be softer and looser. Broccoli and
cauliflower heads tend to have loose margins. Keeping quality is much reduced.
Very high rates of potassium can increase the incidence of cracking in
cabbages, and may also increase tip-burn, and calcium and manganese
deficiencies.
Apart from the above symptoms, K deficiencies show up mainly on leaf
margins, where the older leaves develop chlorosis and grey or tan areas near
the margins, leading to "marginal scorch" or die-back.
The figures supplied in Table 15 give some indication of the N, P & K
requirements of this group of crops.
Table 15: The approximate absorption of nutrients by a good crop of
broccoli and Brussels sprouts
|
|
|
|
Nutrient absorption (kg/ha) |
|
Vegetable |
Yield |
Plant part |
N |
P |
K |
|
Broccoli |
11 t/ha |
Heads |
22 |
2 |
50 |
|
|
Other |
163 |
9 |
185 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brussels sprouts |
18 t/ha |
Sprouts |
168 |
22 |
140 |
|
|
Other |
95 |
10 |
123 |
The absorption of cauliflowers is similar to that of broccoli. The figures
for cabbages, on the other hand, would be more similar to Brussels sprouts;
bear in mind that with cabbage almost the entire plant is marketed, with few
nutrients being returned to the soil in plant residues.
As a general fertilizer dressing on fertile soils, an application of 500 kg
2:3:4 (30) at planting, followed by two dressings of 300 kg LAN, each at 3 and
6 weeks, is suggested. Corresponding figures on less fertile soils are 1000 kg
2:3:4 (30) and two dressings of 250 kg LAN each.
Secondary and micro-nutrients
Calcium (Ca)
Cole crops have a high calcium requirement. Deficiencies may occur
on acid soils, on soils with very high potassium, or on very dry soils where
calcium uptake is reduced.
Deficiencies cause a condition known as tip-burn, where the tips and
margins of leaves become paler and paper thin, and eventually die back.
Tip-burn is thus much more of a problem with cabbages and Brussels sprouts,
because it can affect the edible part of the plant.
Most deficiencies occur where the absorption and translocation of calcium
within the plant are reduced by environmental factors. Drought and high
temperature conditions favour the occurrence of tip-burn and it is thus often
more prevalent in summer crops than in those grown over winter. The use of
calcium nitrate, or similar materials, as foliar sprays, can alleviate the
condition.
Magnesium (Mg)
Magnesium deficiencies occur mainly on acid soils, on very light
soils subject to leaching or on soils with a very high potassium level. It may
be corrected by spraying with 5 kg/ha of magnesium sulphate.
Initially, older leaves show yellowing between the veins. Younger leaves
may be affected later. Older leaves may drop with prolonged deficiency.
Molybdenum (Mo)
Cole crops are very susceptible to a molybdenum deficiency, with
cauliflower accepted as being a very good indicator plant for such
deficiencies. In seedbeds the first indication of a deficiency is a yellowing
of the foliage, similar to that of a nitrogen deficiency. Young developing
leaves become distorted, particularly in cauliflowers, showing the so-called
"whiptail" symptoms; the mid-rib of the leaf develops normally, but
the leaf blade does not fill out properly resulting in narrow, distorted
leaves. The curds tend to be small, open and loose. Leaf symptoms on other
cole crops are much less obvious than on cauliflowers.
Spray the plants with sodium- or ammonium-molybdate at the very first signs
of deficiency, at the rate of 125 g in 500 l water per hectare. Should the
deficiency be severe, a follow-up spray using 60 g of the chemical may be
applied. Malformed leaves will not recover, but subsequent growth should be
normal. Do not over-supply molybdenum as it can harm the plants. Molybdenum
may also reach toxic levels in human tissues, but the levels of the element
derived from consumption of these vegetables is less than from other sources.
Routine spraying may be necessary in areas where molybdenum deficiency occurs.
Adequate liming of acid soils before planting will increase the
availability of molybdenum.
Boron (B)
Soils in the high-rainfall areas of KZN are often low in available
boron, and deficiencies may be expected on such soils. Should deficiencies be
known to occur, cole crops, especially cauliflower, will respond well to
foliar sprays of, for example, Solubor. Usually 3 kg will correct such
deficiencies. Where any bean crop is included in the rotation, rather under-
than over-apply boron, because high rates of boron can be very toxic to these
crops (toxicity symptoms may be manifested in beans when soil boron levels are
above 5 ppm).
A deficiency is characterised by an internal discolouration and cracking of
the stem at the base of the head. A roughness, almost a cork-like appearance,
on the lower surface of the mid-rib of the leaves, also occurs. Deficiency
causes a browning of cauliflower curds. Internal cracking of the stem of
broccoli, without any discolouration, is common when the plants grow rapidly,
especially at lower plant populations. This symptom should not be confused
with a boron deficiency, which causes an internal discolouration.
Manganese (Mn)
Soil manganese is most available to plants on acid soils and may
even reach toxic levels on very acid soils. Deficiencies of this element are
encountered only on soils with a pH (KCI) of over 5.5. The deficiency may be
corrected by a foliar spray of 5 kg/ha of manganese sulphate, or 2 to 3 kg/ha
of manganese oxide, as soon as the deficiency is observed.
The deficiency initially causes yellowish mottled areas to develop between
the veins of the younger leaves. This finally results in an overall pale
appearance. Toxicity levels of manganese and aluminium can be reached in acid
conditions at the root zone of cole crops.
Iron (Fe)
Deficiencies only occur on calcareous, alkaline soils with a pH (KCl)
of over 7,0. Symptoms are very similar to those caused by manganese, and also
occur first on the younger leaves. Yellowing is normally more intense than is
the case with a manganese deficiency.
A foliar spray with 1% iron sulphate or chelate should overcome the
problem.
Zinc (Zn)
Cole crops are less affected by zinc deficiencies than most other
crops.
Irrigation
Brassicas can seldom be grown successfully without at least supplementary
irrigation. They are cool-season, moisture-loving plants, which should never
be exposed to drought-stress.
Until the plants are well-established after transplanting, they should be
kept continually moist, with no more than 25% of the available water being
used before re-watering. Up to about the halfway growth stage no more than 40%
depletion of available water should be allowed. Thereafter the soil may be
allowed to dry a little more, but irrigation should nevertheless take place as
soon as 50% of available water is depleted.
Whilst roots may penetrate more deeply, the effective feeding depth for all
cole crops is only about 600 mm. The crop factors used in irrigation
scheduling are 0.4, 0.6, 0.7 and 0.70 for each fifth of the growing period.
Cauliflower, especially, should not be allowed to wilt once curds have
formed as, apart from reducing yield, the curds may become exposed to the sun
and discolour as a result.
Should there be any delay in marketing, mature heads of cabbages and mature
Brussels sprouts may burst more easily after rain or an irrigation,
particularly if this follows a dry spell.
Weed Control
Weeds need to be adequately controlled because they are efficient
competitors with the crop for nutrients, moisture and sunlight. Some weeds
exude chemical substances which may inhibit the growth of the crop. Many
cruficerous weeds occur, and these are often hosts of diseases and pests of
cole crops. It is very important that weeds be controlled in the early stages
of crop development, because early competition can adversely affect plant
growth and result in the lowering of crop yields. Weed control can be achieved
mechanically, by hand, chemically, or by a combination of these methods.
Mechanical or hand weeding
Mechanical weed control, by cultivation, should begin during land
preparation, and should be repeated, when necessary, until plants are about
half-grown, after which the risk of damaging the crop is too great. Mechanical
cultivation is used between the rows, with some hand weeding being practised
between plants in the row. The first cultivation/hoeing is usually done two or
three weeks after transplanting. Caution should be exercised not to cultivate
too deeply, nor too close to the plants, nor too often. Cole crops respond
well to a cultivation to loosen the soil surface should this become crusted
after heavy rain.
The major problem associated with mechanical or hand weeding is that many
growers delay this operation for too long. Under wet conditions it is
difficult to enter lands timeously, and diseases can be more easily spread
down the rows.
Chemical control
There are several herbicides registered for use on cole crops.
However, the same herbicide may not necessarily be used with safety on the
different types of brassica crops. Cauliflowers, in particular, appear to be
more sensitive than most other crops in this group.
The following chemicals are registered (1998) for use on cruciferous crops:
Alachlor (sold as Alachlor, Sanachlor,
Lasso, Lasso MicroTech and Alanex)
This is registered for use on cabbage and certain cultivars of broccoli and
Brussels sprouts (NOT cauliflower). It is applied as soon as possible after
the first post-transplant irrigation, but pre-emergence of weeds. It controls
mainly annual grasses and, under ideal conditions, yellow nutsedge.
Chlorthal-dimethyl (sold as Dacthal W-75)
Dacthal is applied within 1 day of transplanting to a weed-free, wet
soil-surface on Brussels sprouts, cabbages and cauliflower (NOT broccoli). It
controls mainly annual grasses.
Fluazifop-P-butyl (sold as Fusilade Super
or Grasses)
This is essentially a post-emergent killer of various annual and perennial
grasses and has no, or very little, effect on most broadleaf plants. It is
registered for use on Brussels sprouts.
Metazachlor (sold as Butisan and as
Preecede)
The herbicide is applied directly after transplanting, or within 5 days, but
before weeds emerge. It controls annual grasses mainly, but also certain
broadleaf weeds. It may control yellow nutsedge if conditions are right. The
products are registered for use on broccoli and cabbage, but are known to harm
cauliflowers.
Oxyfluorfen (sold as Goal and as Galigan
240)
Goal is registered for use on all four crops. It controls annual broadleaf
weeds and certain grasses. It must be applied to a well-prepared soil surface.
Transplant into treated soil and irrigate immediately. Under cooler weather
conditions, where inversions occur, some crop damage may result to the young
transplants.
Trifluralin (sold as Trifluralin ,
Digermin and Triflurex)
This chemical may be used on cabbage only. It controls mainly annual grasses
and certain broadleaf weeds. It has a long residual action, which may harm
susceptible successional crops. Trifluralin must be applied to a well-prepared
soil, and must be mechanically incorporated within 10 minutes of application.
Some mechanical or hand weed control may still be advisable, even with the
use of herbicides, because there are certain weeds which are not adequately
controlled with chemicals.
Weed identification
The specific weeds causing the major problem should be identified,
as this assists in the correct choice of the most appropriate herbicide.
Identification, as well as age of weeds, might determine the correct dosage.
Succession crops
The herbicides selected should be considered when the rotational
cropping programme is planned. For example, the earlier use of residual
herbicides (such as atrazine) may detrimentally affect the cole crop grown in
succession. So, also, the use of trifluralin on cabbages could affect the
growth and performance of the following crop if it is sensitive to this
chemical.
Environment
The clay content of the soil determines the dosage required for
many herbicides. Moisture is necessary to transport and activate soil
applications of herbicides. Other factors, such as inversion, may either
detrimentally affect the crop, or may affect the degree of weed control
obtained. When using herbicides the instructions on each container should be
carefully read and followed. They are there for the applicator’s and the
consumer’s protection.
Pests
Cole crops are attacked by many insects, and also sometimes by mites and
nematodes. The severity of attack varies from place to place, and from season
to season. Not all the pests dealt with in this chapter will necessarily
attack a particular planting. The most important pests of cole crops in KZN
are larvae (caterpillars) of various lepidopterous insects, such as American
bollworm, cutworms, diamond-back moth, loopers, greater cabbage moth and
cabbage webworm, and various aphids, of which the grey cabbage aphid and green
peach aphid are the most important. Bagrada bugs, thrips, red spider mite and
nematodes can also cause problems at times.
See Table 16 for chemicals registered for their control.
American bollworm (Helicoverpa armigera)
The American bollworm is a major pest of many crops, including brassicas. The
larvae damage mainly the leaves, and, although they may also feed on
cauliflower and broccoli heads, normally cause more damage to cabbages and
Brussels sprouts, where the edible product consists of leaves. Damage in the
early growth stages of all these crops is often very severe, as their growing
points can be destroyed.
The creamy-white eggs, about half a mm in diameter, are laid singly on the
leaves. They hatch within 3 to 5 days under good conditions. When fully grown
the larvae are up to 40 mm long and have a characteristic undulating white
band on either side of the body. On the upper side are small black spots. The
colour ranges from shades of green and reddish-yellow, to reddish-brown and
black. The underside is greyish white. The larval stage lasts for 2 to 3
weeks. Pupation takes place in the soil. The adult moth has a wingspan of 40
mm and a body length of 18 mm. The forewings have two characteristic brown
markings, while the hindwings have two distinct pale spots. In the warmer
parts of KZN, there are generations throughout the year, although populations
and damage are usually lower with the lower winter temperatures (less than 18ºC).
Cutworm (Agrotis spp.)
Cutworm larvae may damage some of the lower leaves where these touch the
ground. However, the major damage is caused when the stems of young seedlings
are cut off close to ground level. Cutworms feed at night, and during the day
can be found just below the surface of the soil, next to the damaged plant.
The caterpillars, which may reach a length of up to 40 mm, are usually a
greasy grey to dark brown, almost black colour, with several black bumps or
tubercles on each segment. The nocturnal moth has brown or greyish forewings
and light brown hindwings.
Diamond-back moth (Plutella xylostella)
The larvae feed on the under-surface of the leaves without damaging the
epidermis of the upper surface, thus leaving so-called "windows" in
the leaf, which are diagnostic characteristics for these pests. The minute
eggs are usually laid singly on the underside of leaves. The light green
caterpillars are about 10 mm in length, with long slender bodies pointed at
either end, with the pro-legs on the last segment spread apart, forming a
distinctive "V" at the rear end. When disturbed, they wiggle
frantically, or rapidly attach a silken thread to the leaf and drop off the
leaf. They reach maturity in about 10 to 14 days, and then spin loose white
cocoons, which they attach to leaves or stems, and pupate within them. Adult
moths are small and slender, greyish or brownish is colour. Folded, the wings
of the male moths display three distinctive diamond-shaped markings on their
backs, hence the name "diamondback moth". When disturbed they flit
from plant to plant.
Plusia looper (Plusia spp.)
The caterpillars are pale green, with a narrow white stripe along each side,
and move around in the characteristic manner of loopers, by arching their
backs as they propel themselves forward. After feeding for 2 to 4 weeks, the
larvae pupate covered by pieces of leaves, which they have cut and stuck
around the cocoon. The adult moths have bright golden forewings with brown
borders, and brown hindwings. The wingspan is approximately 35 mm.
Greater cabbage moth (Crocidolomia
binotalis)
The young caterpillars are green. Older stages are lined with white and black
spots on the back. The young larvae frequently feed together. They spin a thin
web over their feeding places on the leaves. Most damage is caused by early
attacks when the growing point of the plant is destroyed.
Cabbage webworm (Helula spp.)
These are similar in appearance to the greater cabbage moth and cause similar
damage. They are difficult to control because of their habit of spinning a web
over their feeding places. It is thus difficult to apply chemical sprays to
the feeding site.
Aphids (several kinds)
Various aphids may attack cole crops, the most common being the grey cabbage
aphid, Brevicoryne brassicae, and the green peach aphid, Myzus
persicae. Aphids cause damage by sucking the sap, and are also serious
pests because they contaminate the edible product. The cabbage aphid tends to
form colonies of a dense mass of these insects, and their feeding causes a
chlorosis and malformation of the leaf. The green peach aphid tends to occur
singly.
Bagrada bug (Bagrada hilarus)
These are small black shield bugs, with orange and yellow spots, and an orange
cross on the back. Males and females often run about attached at the rear and
facing away from one another. They are about 8 mm long. They cause damage by
sucking sap from tender growth, resulting in a whitish, scarred appearance.
Heavy infestation can seriously reduce growth and yields.
Thrips
The most important species on crucifers is generally Thrips
tabaci. These small insects seldom cause serious damage but, when
populations are high, are undesirable because of the contamination of the
product by their very presence.
Red spider mite (Tetranychus urticae)
These minute reddish-brown "spiders", with four pairs of legs of
equal length, and an oval body, are usually found on the underside of leaves,
but also on tender young heads of broccoli and cauliflower. They weave a fine
web on the lower surfaces of leaves. They are sucking insects and cause a
bronzing and yellowing of leaves, and on broccoli heads a grey scarring on
young stems.
Nematodes
Cole crops are affected by various nematodes, but damage is seldom
serious unless populations are very high. Affected plants are unthrifty and
may become stunted. They may show symptoms of moisture or nutrient stress.
Table 16: Pesticides registered in 1999 for
controlling various pests in crucifers
|
Chemical |
Formulation |
Safe Period (days) |
Sold as |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
|
acephate |
SP 750 g/kg |
3 |
Acephate, Orthene, Ace, Racet 750 SP |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| alphacypermethrin |
SC 100 g/l |
4 |
Concord, Fastac |
T |
T |
T |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| alphacypermethrin |
EC 100 g/l |
4 |
Bestox, Fastac |
% |
% |
% |
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
| Bacillus thuringiensis var. aizawai |
WG |
|
Xen tari, Florbas |
T |
|
T |
T |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Bacillus thuringienis var. kurstaki |
WP |
- |
Thuricide, Dipel, Dipel 2X, Biobit |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| betacyfluthrin |
EC 50 g/l |
4 |
Bulldock |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| carbofuran |
GR 100 g/kg |
77 |
Carbofuran, Curaterr, Furadan, Agriterr, Alvuran |
|
|
%
Ë |
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
| chlorphenapyr |
SC 240 g/l |
7 |
Cordless |
|
|
T
g |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| chlorpyrifos |
EC 480 g/l |
7 |
Pyrinex, Chlorpyrifos, Dursban, Lorsban, Avi-klorpirifos,
Agropyriphos, Lirifos, Phantom,, Pyrifos, Rochlop |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| cyfluthrin |
EC 50 g/l |
4 |
Baythroid |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| cypermethrin |
EC 200 g/l or 20 g/l |
4 |
Cypermethrin, Ripcord, Magnum, Doodskoot, Sipermethrin,
Cymbush, Avi-sipermethrin, Ripcord 11, Garden Ripcord, Fruitfly,
Supermethrin, Sherpa, Ploythrin, Rocyper |
% |
% |
% |
|
T |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
| cypermethrin-high cis |
EC 200 g/l |
4 |
Fenom |
% |
% |
% |
|
T |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
| delta endotoxin |
SC 200 g/l |
- |
MVP 11 Bio Insecticide |
|
|
T |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
| deltamethrin |
EC 25 g/l |
3 |
Decis |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| demeton-S-methyl |
EC 250 g/l |
10 |
Demetox, Demeton |
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| diazinon |
EC 275 g/l |
14 |
Diazinon, Kayazinon |
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
% |
|
| dichlorvos |
EC 1000 g/l |
2 |
Dichlorvos, Dedevap, Devipan, Nogos, DDVP, Divos |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| dicofol |
WP 185 g/kg |
7 |
Kelthane |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
| dimethoate |
EC 400 g/l |
14 |
Dimethoate, Fetron, Aphicide, Dimet, Dimeto, Aphids, Rogor,
Perfekthion |
|
|
|
|
|
|
%
** |
|
|
|
|
| disulfoton |
GR 50 g/kg |
42 |
Disyston |
|
|
%
* |
|
|
|
%
* |
|
|
|
|
| endosulfan |
SC 475 g/l |
- |
Endoflo, Thioflo |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
| endosulfan |
WP 475 g/kg |
7 |
Endosulfan, Thionex |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| endosulfan |
DP 50 g/kg |
7 |
Endosulfan |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| gamma-BHC |
EC 200 g/l |
30 |
Lindane, Dyant,Ants, Ant and Garden Spray |
|
|
|
|
|
|
%
Ë
Ë |
%
Ë
Ë |
|
|
|
| gamma-BHC |
DP 6 g/kg |
30 |
Lindaan, Bexadust |
|
|
%
Ë
Ë |
|
|
|
|
%
Ë
Ë |
|
|
|
| lambda-cyhalothrin |
EC 50 g/l |
2 |
Karate |
% |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| mercaptothion |
WP 250 g/kg |
7 |
Mercaptothion, merkaptotoks |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| mercaptothion |
EC 500 g/l |
7 |
Mercaptothion, Malathion, Datathion, Malasol,
Avigard,Garden Insects |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| mercaptothion |
DP 50 g/kg |
7 |
Kopthion, Avi-mercaptothion , Stink powder |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| methamidophos |
SL 585 g/l |
21 |
Methamidophos, Sniper, Thamida, Methamidofos, Patrole,
Rometra, Tamafos, Tamaron, Methaphos, Midofos |
|
|
% |
|
T |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| methomyl |
SP 900 g/kg |
4 |
Methomyl, Lannate, Methomex, Kuik, Methosan |
% |
|
% |
|
T |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| methomyl |
SL 200 g/l |
4 |
Methomyl, Lannate, Methomex |
% |
|
% |
|
T |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| mevinphos |
EC 150 g/l |
4 |
Mevinphos, Phosdrin |
|
|
% |
|
T |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| oxydemeton-methyl |
EC 250 g/l |
10 : 14 |
Metasystox-R |
|
|
|
|
|
|
%
*** |
|
|
|
|
| oxydemeton-methyl |
SL 100 g/l |
10. 14 |
Metasystox - R Liquid |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| parathion |
EC 500 g/l |
21 |
Parathion |
|
|
% |
|
T |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
| phenthoate |
EC 500 g/l |
3 |
Elsan |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| phorate |
GR 100 g/kg |
56 |
Phorate , Thimet |
|
|
% |
|
|
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
| pirimicarb |
WG 62,5 g/kg |
7 |
Aphox |
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| pirimicarb |
AE 1 g/kg |
7 |
Pirimor Aphid Killer |
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| profenofos (premium grade) |
EC 500 g/l |
7 : 10
$ |
Selecron |
|
% |
% |
% |
% |
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| pymetrozine |
WP 250 g/l |
7 |
Chess |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| thiometon |
EC 250 g/l |
28 |
Ekatin |
|
|
|
|
|
|
% |
|
|
|
|
| tralomethrin |
EC 36 g/l |
3 |
Tralate, Sibling |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| trichlorfon |
SP 950 g/kg |
7 |
Trichlorfon, Dipterex, Dipterex Soluble Powder |
|
% |
% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
To prevent contamination of clean fields, wash machinery with high-pressure
equipment to remove contaminated soil and other debris before moving from
infected to non-infected fields. Prevent water movement from infected to clean
fields. Ensure that infected plant material does not move over. Grow
transplants in fumigated beds; young plants can be infected for some time
before showing symptoms and cannot always be identified at transplanting.
Speedlings (even from commercial speedling growers) irrigated with
contaminated water can become infected, so ensure that the water source is not
affected.
Clubroot spores do not germinate well in alkaline soil, so liming may help
reduce disease incidence. However, liming may not be effective in
well-buffered soil. Apply lime annually if the soil pH is below 7.
There is some evidence to suggest that a two- or more year rotation away
from cruciferous crops, and into a cereal, can markedly reduce clubroot
incidence.
Typical symptoms on cole crops are stunting and irregular patches of yellow
developing between major veins of older leaves. These symptoms are not obvious
and may be overlooked. A diagonal cross-section through an infected stem will
show discontinuous streaks of dark-brown discolouration in the woody,
water-conducting vessels. Discoloured streaks also occur near the base of
petioles. Streaking and leaf symptoms may be one-sided, as in Fusarium Wilt,
in early infections. Verticillium does not kill cole plants, but it can
limit yields. Cool soil and air temperatures favour infection and disease
symptom development.
The fungus can persist in the soil for several years. Rotation is of little
value because of the wide host range. There are no economically feasible
controls available. Avoiding stress in the later part of the growing season
may help limit damage.
The fungus can persist indefinitely in the soil, even with long periods of
unfavourable temperature and drought. The fungus is spread with infected
plants and in infected soil on farm machinery, drainage water, boots or tools.
Once in a field it is dispersed through cultivation and other practices that
move soil or plant debris about.
White mould occurs on many crops, such as carrots, lettuce, beans, celery,
potatoes, tomatoes and sunflower, as well as cole crops, where it can be a
particular problem for seed production. Cool, wet conditions favour disease
development.
During wet weather any of the above-ground parts of infected plants may be
covered with a white cottony growth. The plant tissue beneath the white
mycelium usually turns soft and watery. Hard, black resting bodies - sclerotia
- are produced in or on diseased tissue. These sclerotia enable the pathogen
to survive in the soil for up to 2 or 3 years.
This organism is also favoured by cool, moist conditions. It can be
seedborne, or survive in plant debris in the soil.
The most distinctive characteristic of downy mildew is the greyish white,
fluffy growth that develops on the underside of infected leaves. Irregular
yellow to brown spots develop on both leaf surfaces. These spots may turn
purplish and later light brown or yellow. On seedlings leaf drop is common.
Infection may spread to stems or flower parts. Dark brown or blackened areas
will develop internally in curds or floral stems of cauliflower or broccoli,
making them unmarketable. In the stems and heads of cabbage, the fungus may
produce dark purplish spots; this internal darkening may not be visible until
affected parts are sliced open. Secondary rots may develop. The fungus
survives in over-lapping cruciferous crops. Sexual spores can survive in the
soil for extended periods.
The first symptoms are small, dark tan spots that enlarge rapidly and turn
grey. Older spots are usually made up of a series of concentric rings.
Numerous tiny dark bodies develop within the aging lesion. Lesions may cause
severe defoliation, thus reducing yields. Affected sprouts showing spots are
unmarketable.
The fungus can survive on infected plant refuse in the soil.
The spores are spread from plant to plant by the wind under favourable
conditions. During unfavourable periods the fungus can survive in plant
debris. Infected seed is a major source of inoculum for new outbreaks.
Raised white pustules form on the lower surfaces of leaves, with a
yellowing on the opposite side of the leaf. Pustules sometimes have a greenish
tint, but are generally pure white and look almost as though white enamel
paint has been splashed onto affected parts. These pustules have also been
observed on broccoli heads; affected buds are white and are stimulated to grow
very large, with some malformation. Affected heads are not marketable. Under
favourable cool, moist conditions the spread and development of the disease is
rapid.
This fungus is closely related to that causing downy mildew and can
probably be controlled in a similar manner to downy mildew. Whilst no
chemicals are registered for use against white blister in South Africa, sprays
against downy mildew will frequently keep it in check.
The bacteria may be carried over in, or on, the seed of infected crucifers,
on host plants, including cruciferous weeds, or in infected plant refuse in
the soil. Splashing water from sprinkler irrigation or rain commonly
disseminates the bacteria within a field. The bacteria enter the plant through
natural openings at the margins of the leaves or through insect wounds.
The disease appears first as small, faint, water-soaked areas on the
underside of leaves. These areas develop in a few days into
brownish-to-purplish grey necrotic spots, somewhat irregular in outline. They
may coalesce to form large irregularly-shaped spots. When the lesions are
numerous, the leaf becomes puckered and the affected tissue may tear.
The bacterium is capable of living in soil and in infected plant material.
It is believed to be seedborne.
It gives rise to a soft, watery rot of affected plant parts and to an
unpleasant odour. It is considered to be only weakly parasitic, needing a
wound or injury to enter the plant. Sunburn, or insect or mechanical injuries,
are points of entry.
No control measures are generally practised.